Working with Categories

As you can see from the last couple of posts, I started my testing of Quicken Essentials for Mac by starting from scratch, rather than importing my Quicken 2006 file. I'll get to that later.

Starting from scratch, QEM downloaded about three months worth of transactions. One of the things that it did was to assign categories to most of the transactions:

As you can see, it did an okay job. It correctly categorized the two Dining transactions, and figured out that Trader Joe's is a grocery store. It didn't know what to do with the post office transactions, and said that the Amazon purchase was a gift when it wasn't.

QEM comes with a starter set of categories:

Assigning a category to those two USPS transactions is simple enough: double-click on the category column for that transaction and you go into edit mode:

You can then either click on one of the categories, or start typing to narrow down the list:

Hit return to finish:

Okay, two things to be careful about:

• I like typing. When the shortened lists of categories came up, like you see two pictures up, I wanted to be able to use arrow keys to pick a different category. I first tried using the right arrow key, since the categories are laid out in a grid, but that didn't work. You need to use the up and down arrow keys to cycle through. While this is just like how Quicken 2006 works, it was unexpected -- hitting the down arrow key to move right is weird.

• QEM will not warn you before creating a new category based on what you type:

Moneywell impressions, part 1 - buckets are not categories

As I mentioned a few weeks ago, I gave Moneywell a whirl.  Overall, I don't think Moneywell is going to work well for me, but your mileage may vary.

Moneywell supports the envelope theory of budget management. In Moneywell, every time you get some cash in, it turns into an inflow, which you can then allocate to different areas. Traditional envelope theory has you cashing your paycheck and getting paper envelopes; Moneywell uses the idea of buckets.

I guess my big problem with Moneywell's bucket implementation is the difference between buckets and categories.  Take, for example, my insurance bill. I've got life, auto, and home insurance with the same company.  The bill is monthly and fairly regular (maybe adjusting once every six months as a new auto premium is calculated), and there's just one bill that combines all three. From a bucket-budget planning standpoint, I just want to have one bucket -- "insurance" -- that money moves into and comes out from.

But, every once in a while, I want to be able to look back and get more granularity.  If I was shopping around for a different auto insurer, I might want to look back and see how much I had been spending on auto insurance. 

There's the rub with Moneywell -- if you want granularity, you need more buckets -- one per grain, so to speak.  But...the more buckets you've got, the more complicated every payday gets, and most of the time, you don't need that much detail.